Docs SEO
Missing pages return 404
Requests a made-up URL on your site and checks it returns a real 404 status, not a soft 404 or a redirect to the homepage.
What it checks
We request a made-up address on the site your homepage lands on, such as /sb-missing-page-ab12cd34, and follow any redirects.
If that request gets no answer, a 403, a 429 or a 5xx error, the check is left out of the report, because that answer says the server blocked us or had a problem, not how it treats missing pages.
- PassThe made-up URL returns 404 or 410.
- FailAny other status, including a redirect to the homepage.
Why it matters
When a missing page answers 200, or redirects everything to the homepage, search engines see a working page. That is a soft 404: they can keep empty pages in their index, waste crawl time on them, and dead links look alive. Google says it may treat a redirect from a missing page to the homepage as a soft 404.
How to fix it
Make the server answer URLs that do not exist with a 404 status and a helpful page that links back into the site. Only redirect old URLs that have a clear replacement page.
Single page apps often send the same page with a 200 for every URL and show the not-found message in the browser. The status has to come from the server or the host.
Platform notes
Both return a real 404 by default. A fail usually comes from a plugin or app that redirects every missing page to the homepage.
Next.js returns 404 for unknown routes and when you call notFound(). A catch-all rewrite to index.html in vercel.json or a Netlify _redirects file turns every missing page into a 200. Netlify serves your 404.html with a 404 status when there is no such rewrite.
On Cloudflare Pages, a project without a top-level 404.html is treated as a single page app and answers every path with index.html. Add a 404.html.
The common single page app rule that falls back to index.html for every path returns 200 for missing pages. Fall back to a 404 for paths your app does not know, and use error_page 404 or ErrorDocument 404 for the page.
Your report shows what this check found on your site. Pro shows the exact fix for your site. See pricing.
Want to test just this? Use the free Soft 404 checker.
Questions
Should I redirect missing pages to the homepage?
No. Redirect an old address only when a page replaces it. Otherwise let it return 404 with a helpful not-found page that links back into the site.
Free, about 30 seconds, with every other check included.